Jessica has years of experience representing clients in litigation matters, including estate and trust litigation, business litigation, juvenile custody and child support actions, divorce, dissolutions, and adoptions. She believes in providing quality representation for clients while maintaining sensitivity to their individualized needs during stressful litigation.

After graduating at the top of her class from Capital University Law School, Jessica went on to work for the Capital Legal Clinic as a Staff Attorney. She subsequently moved into the private sector as an associate at a boutique law firm providing services to clients in probate, juvenile, and civil litigation matters. Jessica joined Arenstein & Andersen Co., LPA in March 2015 and is presently a Shareholder. In 2022-2023, Jessica was named to the Columbus CEO’s Top Lawyers List.

Jessica is a central Ohio native who presently resides in the Worthington area with her husband, John, and their two sons, Jack and Luke.  In her spare time, she enjoys spending time with her family (including her two dogs, Cooper & Murphy), obsessively cleaning/organizing, and taking part in various outdoor activities.


B.A. Ohio State University, Political Science & English – Columbus, OH
J.D. Capital University Law School. Magna Cum Laude – Columbus, OH

  • CALI Awards for Excellence for Top Grade and Performance: General Litigation Clinic, Employment Law, Immigration Law, and Energy Law
  • Order of the Curia
  • Roberta Mitchell’s Award for Excelling in Legal Clinic


Supreme Court of the State of Ohio
United States District Supreme Court for the Southern District of Ohio
United States District Supreme Court for the Northern District of Ohio

Bar Memberships

Columbus Bar Association